HUB hero image

How to Travel from

Ithaca to Fire Island

by Plane, Rideshare, Route or Car

Ithaca
+0
Fire Island
Transport search to Fire Island
Ithaca
+0
Fire Island
Building a composite car route
Cheapest
Best Offer!
Car
5 h 22 min
451 km.
from $24
Composite Route Car Only

Ten ways to Travel from Ithaca to Fire Island

Select an Option Below to Start Your Journey
Cheapest
Fastest
Other

Transport providers

Airlines

JetBlue Airways

Website:
jetblue.com/
Plane from Syracuse Hancock International Airport to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 25m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$89.17–$407.64

Delta

Website:
delta.com/
Plane from Ithaca Tompkins Regional Airport to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 28m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$89.17–$369.42
Plane from Syracuse Hancock International Airport to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 24m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$59.87–$242.03
Plane from Syracuse Hancock International Airport to Laguardia
Ave. Duration:
1h 13m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$63.69–$267.51

United Airlines

Website:
united.com/
Plane from Ithaca Tompkins Regional Airport to Newark
Ave. Duration:
1h 26m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$292.99–$458.59

Bus operators

Flixbus USA

Phone:
+1 (855) 626-8585
Website:
flixbus.com
Bus from Ithaca to New
Ave. Duration:
4h 20m
Frequency:
3 times a day
Estimated price:
$22.93–$89.17

OurBus

Phone:
+1-844-800-6828
Website:
ourbus.com
Bus from Ithaca, NY to Park
Ave. Duration:
4h
Frequency:
4 times a week
Estimated price:
$7.64–$70.06
Bus from Ithaca, NY to Syracuse
Ave. Duration:
1h 45m
Frequency:
4 times a week
Estimated price:
$7.64–$54.78

Trailways

Phone:
+1 800-858-8555
Website:
trailways.com
Bus from Ithaca to Port
Ave. Duration:
4h 45m
Frequency:
Twice daily
Estimated price:
$53.50–$121.02

Train operators

Long Island Rail Road

Phone:
+1-718-217-5477
Website:
mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road
Train from New York Penn Station to Babylon
Ave. Duration:
1h 15m
Frequency:
Every 30 minutes
Estimated price:
$3.69–$20.38
Train from Jamaica to Babylon
Ave. Duration:
52 min
Frequency:
Every 20 minutes
Estimated price:
$3.69–$17.83
Train from New York Penn Station to Central
Ave. Duration:
1h 14m
Frequency:
Every 30 minutes
Estimated price:
$3.69–$22.93
Train from Woodside to Babylon
Ave. Duration:
49 min
Frequency:
Every 2 hours
Estimated price:
$3.69–$19.11

Questions and Answers

What is the cheapest way to get from Ithaca to Fire Island?

The cheapest way to get from Ithaca to Fire Island is to bus and train via New York which costs $11.96 - $76.09 and takes 7h 15m.

What is the fastest way to get from Ithaca to Fire Island?

The fastest way to get from Ithaca to Fire Island is to drive which takes 5h 24m and costs $50 - $76.09 .

How far is it from Ithaca to Fire Island?

The distance between Ithaca and Fire Island is 439 km. The road distance is 453.4 km.

How do I travel from Ithaca to Fire Island without a car?

The best way to get from Ithaca to Fire Island without a car is to bus and train via New York which takes 7h 15m and costs $11.96 - $76.09 .

How long does it take to get from Ithaca to Fire Island?

It takes approximately 7h 15m to get from Ithaca to Fire Island, including transfers.

Can I drive from Ithaca to Fire Island?

Yes, the driving distance between Ithaca to Fire Island is 453 km. It takes approximately 5h 24m to drive from Ithaca to Fire Island.

Where can I stay near Fire Island?

There are 70+ hotels available in Fire Island. Prices start at $74.33 per night.
+0