HUB hero image

How to Travel from

Buffalo to Shelter Island

by Rideshare, Route or Car

Buffalo
+0
Shelter Island
Transport search to Shelter Island
Buffalo
+0
Shelter Island
Building a composite car route
Cheapest
Best Offer!
Car
8 h 59 min
775 km.
from $42
Composite Route Car Only

Eleven ways to Travel from Buffalo to Shelter Island

Select an Option Below to Start Your Journey
Cheapest
Other

Transport providers

Airlines

JetBlue Airways

Website:
jetblue.com/
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 38m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$108.28–$547.76
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to General
Ave. Duration:
1h 39m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$108.28–$624.19
Plane from Rochester to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 31m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$108.28–$407.64

American Airlines

Website:
aa.com/
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Laguardia
Ave. Duration:
1h 22m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$121.02–$1,401.25
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to General
Ave. Duration:
3h 47m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$165.60–$624.19

Delta

Website:
delta.com/
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 32m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$70.06–$267.51
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Laguardia
Ave. Duration:
1h 26m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$76.43–$292.99
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to General
Ave. Duration:
4h 2m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$95.54–$305.73
Plane from Rochester to John
Ave. Duration:
1h 27m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$63.69–$254.77
Plane from Rochester to Laguardia
Ave. Duration:
1h 15m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$70.06–$267.51

United Airlines

Website:
united.com/
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Laguardia
Ave. Duration:
3h 38m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$165.60–$955.39
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to Newark
Ave. Duration:
1h 36m
Frequency:
Every day
Estimated price:
$127.39–$573.24
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to General
Ave. Duration:
4h 3m
Frequency:
Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Sunday
Estimated price:
$203.82–$764.32

Southwest Airlines

Website:
southwest.com/
Plane from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to General
Ave. Duration:
3h 53m
Frequency:
Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Sunday
Estimated price:
$254.77–$891.70

Train operators

Amtrak

Phone:
+1 800-872-7245
Website:
amtrak.com/home.html
Train from Buffalo to Ny
Ave. Duration:
8h 17m
Frequency:
3 times a day
Estimated price:
$52.23–$191.08
Train from Buffalo to Rochester
Ave. Duration:
1h 12m
Frequency:
3 times a day
Estimated price:
$11.46–$82.80

Amtrak Northeast Regional

Phone:
+1 800-872-7245
Website:
amtrak.com/home.html
Train from Boston to Old
Ave. Duration:
1h 41m
Frequency:
Every 4 hours
Estimated price:
$25.48–$242.03

VIA Rail

Phone:
+1 888 842-7245
Website:
viarail.ca/en
Train from Buffalo to Rochester
Ave. Duration:
1h 9m
Frequency:
Once daily
Estimated price:
$19.11–$95.54
Train from Buffalo to New
Ave. Duration:
8h 51m
Frequency:
Once daily
Estimated price:
$63.69–$127.39

Long Island Rail Road

Phone:
+1-718-217-5477
Website:
mta.info/agency/long-island-rail-road
Train from Jamaica to Ronkonkoma
Ave. Duration:
1h
Frequency:
Every 30 minutes
Estimated price:
$3.69–$21.66
Train from Ronkonkoma to Greenport
Ave. Duration:
1h 35m
Frequency:
3 times a day
Estimated price:
$12.10–$17.83
Train from Woodside to Ronkonkoma
Ave. Duration:
1h 10m
Frequency:
Hourly
Estimated price:
$3.69–$22.93
Train from New York Penn Station to Bridgehampton
Ave. Duration:
2h
Frequency:
Once a week
Estimated price:
$3.69–$42.04

Bus operators

Flixbus USA

Phone:
+1 (855) 626-8585
Website:
flixbus.com
Bus from Buffalo to New
Ave. Duration:
8h
Frequency:
5 times a day
Estimated price:
$39.49–$127.39

Hampton Jitney Inc.

Phone:
+1 631.283.4600
Website:
hamptonjitney.com
Bus from 6th Ave btwn 37th & 38th St to Sag
Ave. Duration:
2h 58m
Frequency:
On demand
Estimated price:
$36.94–$82.80
Bus from Boerum Hill-Atlantic & 4 Av to Greenport
Ave. Duration:
3h 58m
Frequency:
On demand
Estimated price:
$36.94–$82.80

Questions and Answers

What is the cheapest way to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island?

The cheapest way to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island is to bus which costs $65.22 - $184.78 and takes 11h 51m.

What is the fastest way to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island?

The fastest way to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island is to fly and train which takes 7h 4m and costs $108.70 - $597.83 .

How far is it from Buffalo to Shelter Island?

The distance between Buffalo and Shelter Island is 645 km.

How do I travel from Buffalo to Shelter Island without a car?

The best way to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island without a car is to bus which takes 11h 51m and costs $65.22 - $184.78 .

How long does it take to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island?

It takes approximately 7h 5m to get from Buffalo to Shelter Island, including transfers.

Where can I stay near Shelter Island?

There are 159+ hotels available in Shelter Island. Prices start at $88.43 per night.
+0